We Tested 236 Sheet Sets to Find the Best Places to Buy Bedding Online (2024)

The Citizenry

The Citizenry is the most expensive bedding brand on our list, but given its commitment to quality and artisanship (which we validated in our testing!), we think it’s worth the splurge. We’ve found that the brand’s sheets are light and airy yet still durable and stain resistant.

Though The Citizenry’s bedding section is small and curated, it’s packed with quality finds. All of its items are Standard 100 certified by Oeko-Tex and handcrafted by artisans across the globe. And since they’re sold as sets and separates, you can stock up on exactly what you need.

Whereas some bedding brands have limited color selections, The Citizenry offers its pieces in a range of hues and prints. The brand’s Stonewashed Linen Sheet Set—which was one of the best linen sheets we tested—is available in 13 colors and three prints.

Though The Citizenry’s pieces are pricey, the store offers free shipping on most items. And shipping takes between seven and 10 days—though if you’re buying a low-stock item, it can take much longer. Just make sure you’re confident with your purchase, as the Citizenry gives you just 30 days to return most items and charges a $25 fee on many returns.

Real Simple Selects-Approved Products:

• Stonewashed Linen Sheet Set
• Organic Resort Cotton Sheet Set

Materials: Cotton, linen, wool, down alternative | Product Variety: Sheets, pillowcases, duvet covers, quilts, blankets, shams, duvet inserts, bedding bundles | Certifications: Standard 100 by Oeko-Tex, GOTS | Return Policy: 30 days

Parachute

Looking to invest in premium bedding? Parachute has you covered. The brand was founded in 2014 to deliver luxe bedding straight to your doorstep, and years later, it’s still one of our favorite spots for cozy, investment-worthy pieces. When we test Parachute sheets, we often describe them as breathable, durable, and soft to the touch.

Parachute sells every kind of bedding product imaginable: sheets, quilts, shams, comforters—even pillows and duvet inserts. And since the brand sells sets and separates, it’s easy to stock up on exactly what you need. All of Parachute’s products are Oeko-Tex Standard 100 certified, meaning they're made without harmful chemicals. And although Parachute specializes in luxe materials—like organic cotton, European flax linen, and washed velvet—almost all of its bedding is machine-washable.

One of our favorite things about Parachute is that it offers free 60-day returns on most of its pieces—giving you plenty of time to decide how you feel about your latest purchase. It also offers free standard shipping on all orders and provides complimentary design services. And if you need anything, you can reach customer service via chat or email, or you can set up a scheduled phone appointment.

Real Simple Selects-Approved Products:

• Linen Sheet Set
• Down Pillow
• Percale Sheet Set

Materials: Cotton, linen, down, down alternative | Product Variety: Sheets, pillowcases, duvet covers, comforters, quilts, blankets, shams, pillows, specialty pillows, duvet inserts, mattress pads, mattress protectors, bedding bundles | Certifications: Standard 100 by Oeko-Tex, GOTS | Return Policy: 60 days

Coyuchi

If you’re committed to buying organic sheets, give Coyuchi a look. We’ve tested four different sheet sets from the brand, and we found that they are great at wicking away moisture and resisting stains. We also appreciate that its sheets have deep pockets to prevent them from sliding off thick mattresses. The brand also makes some of the most beautiful blankets and quilts you can find, and its products meet the highest standards for quality, sustainability, and organic practices.

Many bedding brands focus on essentials, like sheets, pillows, and duvets. Coyuchi covers these bases—offering organic cotton sheets, wool duvet inserts, and handy bedding bundles. But it also goes beyond the basics, selling artisan blankets, handmade quilts, and other special finds. These handcrafted items set Coyuchi apart from other bedding brands, and since they’re handcrafted, we think they’re worth the splurge.

Coyuchi holds itself to high-quality standards, so its bedding is packed with certifications. All of Coyuchi’s products are Global Organic Textile Standard (GOTS), Fair Trade, and Made Safe certified.

The brand also offers free shipping on orders over $300—a high threshold, but one that’s easy to meet when shopping at the store. And if you’re hesitant to invest, Coyuchi’s whopping 365-day return policy on most items should ease your mind. Customer service is also easy to reach: Just chat with, email, or call them, or fill out a submission form on the website.

Real Simple Selects-Approved Products:

• Organic Relaxed Linen Sheets
• Organic Crinkled Percale Sheets
• Cloud Brushed Organic Flannel Sheets

Materials: Organic cotton, organic linen, wool, down, organic latex | Product Variety: Sheets, pillowcases, duvet covers, comforters, quilts, blankets, shams, pillows, speciality pillows, duvet inserts, pillow protectors, mattress pads, bedding bundles | Certifications: GOTS, Fair Trade, Made Safe | Return Policy: 1 year

Brooklinen

If you want to score a deal on high-quality bedding, Brooklinen is the place to shop. Founded by textile experts, the brand specializes in top-notch essentials that don’t cost a fortune.

Brooklinen sells everything you need to outfit your bed from top to bottom, including sheets, quilts, throw blankets, memory foam pillows, mattress toppers, and duvet inserts. These items are sold separately and in sets, so you can buy exactly what you need. Just check what comes in your bedding bundle before buying it—some include flat sheets, while others don’t.

Most of Brooklinen’s sheets are Oeko Tex Standard 100 certified, meaning they’re made without harmful chemicals. And the brand’s down comforters and pillows are certified by the Down Association of Canada (Downmark), meaning they’re made from top-quality materials.

Our favorite thing about buying from Brooklinen? The brand offers 365-day returns on most products. Unfortunately, it recently started charging $10 fees for returns. And while most items ship in four to 10 days, the brand only offers free shipping when you spend over $100.

Real Simple Selects-Approved Products:

• All-Season Down Comforter
• Linen Core Sheet Set

Materials: Cotton, linen, cashmere, mulberry silk, down, down alternative, memory foam | Product Variety: Sheets, pillowcases, duvet covers, quilts, throw blankets, shams, pillows, duvet inserts, pillow protectors, mattress toppers, bedding bundles | Certifications: Standard 100 by Oeko-Tex, Downmark | Return Policy: 1 year

Amazon

Amazon is called “the everything store” for a reason—it truly has it all. So it should come as no surprise that Amazon has plenty of great bedding worth considering.

On Amazon, you can find pretty bed linens, like sheets, comforters, throw blankets, and shams. You can also score essentials, like mattress toppers and pillow protectors. And the store really shines when you need something specific, like a fitted sheet for a twin XL bed or a temperature-regulating pillow insert. Most bedding brands sell just a few of these items—if they sell them at all. Being able to buy everything you need in one place is endlessly convenient.

Since Amazon aggregates products from other retailers, its bedding selection isn’t very curated. But when it comes to variety and convenience, the retailer can’t be beat. Its website is easy to navigate, orders take no time to place, and customer service is quick to respond (especially if you use the chat box). And while shipping and return policies vary from third-party seller to third-party seller, Amazon Prime members can typically expect free shipping and free 30-day returns on most items.

Real Simple Selects-Approved Products:

• Bampure Bamboo Bed Sheets
• Utopia Bedding Down-Alternative Comforter
• Linenspa Shredded Memory Foam Pillow
• Lucid Ventilated Gel-Infused Memory Foam Mattress Topper (From $70 for queen)

Materials: Cotton, polyester, linen, eucalyptus lyocell, bamboo rayon, wool, down, down alternative, memory foam, gel | Product Variety: Sheets, pillowcases, duvet covers, quilts, comforters, throw blankets, shams, pillows, duvet inserts, pillow protectors, mattress protectors, mattress toppers, bedding bundles | Certifications: Varies by product | Return Policy: 30 days

Boll & Branch

Boll & Branch sells a range of home essentials, but it’s best known for its bedding. The brand’s organic cotton sheets are some of the finest around, and we especially loved the Signature Hemmed Sheet Set in our testing.

The organic cotton sheets come in three ultra-soft weaves: silky-smooth sateen, crisp percale, and breathable chambray. And since Boll & Branch’s cotton is GOTS and Standard 100 by Oeko-Tex certified, you can rest assured knowing you're paying for quality. The brand’s quilts and blankets are made of top-quality organic cotton, and its down pillows, down duvet inserts, and alpaca wool throws are made of responsibly sourced materials.

Most Boll & Branch items ship within six days and arrive in elegant packaging that makes a great first impression. Unfortunately, the return window is nothing to write home about—just 30 days. But if you notice that something you bought has been marked down within two weeks of your purchase, the brand will grant you a partial refund, thus giving you the discount you missed out on. And you can easily reach customer service via text, call, or email.

Real Simple Selects-Approved Products:

• Down Chamber Pillow
• Signature Hemmed Sheet Set

Materials: Organic cotton, flax linen, wool, down, down alternative | Product Variety: Sheets, pillowcases, duvet covers, quilts, blankets, pillows, duvet inserts | Certifications: Standard 100 by Oeko-Tex, GOTS | Return Policy: 30 days

Cozy Earth

Want to stock up on top-quality bedding made of natural materials? Cozy Earth is the right place to turn. The brand specializes in sleep essentials—like bedding and pajamas—that are soft, breathable, and perfect for cozying up with.

Its bedding comes in just two fabrics: bamboo viscose and a bamboo-linen blend, both of which we’ve tested. While both materials are cooling and breathable, we recommend the bamboo sheets for people who sleep hot and prefer a silky-smooth texture. Cozy Earth also sells nice-to-haves, like silk pillows, silk/bamboo comforters, and bamboo blankets—and many of these items arrive inside a reusable tote bag.

Some, but not all, Cozy Earth products are listed as Oeko-Tex Standard 100 certified. But the brand offers some of the most generous shipping and return policies around—free shipping on orders over $50, a 100-day trial period, and a 10-year warranty. It’s also easy to get in touch with customer service: You can email, call, or chat with them, or fill out a submission form on the website.

Real Simple Selects-Approved Products:

• Bamboo Comforter
• Bamboo Sheet Set

Materials: Bamboo rayon, bamboo-linen blend, silk | Product Variety: Sheets, pillowcases, duvet covers, blankets, shams, pillows, duvet inserts, mattress pads, bedding bundles | Certifications: Standard 100 by Oeko-Tex | Return Policy: 100 days

Saatva

Although Saatva started as a luxury mattress company, it’s since expanded to offer a range of upscale bedding basics, like splurge-worthy sheets and pillows. We’ve tested all types of bedding from the brand, but we’re partial to the Percale Sheet Set, which washes extremely well and provides plenty of airflow.

Saatva’s bedding selection is small, easy to navigate, and packed with top-notch finds. Its sheets are made of premium materials, like organic cotton and Belgian flax linen. And its covers range from lightweight cotton-viscose quilts to cozy cotton-velvet blankets. The brand also stands out for its luxe mattress toppers and pillows, which are made of quality materials, like graphite-infused memory foam and hypoallergenic latex, and covered with organic cotton.

All of Saatva’s bedding is certified Standard 100 by Oeko-Tex, and its organic pieces are GOTS certified. If you need help while shopping, you can consult a Saatva sleep guide by messaging in a chatbox or calling the brand over the phone. The site offers free shipping on all bedding, free 45-day returns, and 180-day returns on mattress toppers. Our only complaint? It can take five to eight days for your order to ship, which is long compared to some of our other favorite places to buy sheets.

Real Simple Selects-Approved Products:

• Graphite Mattress Topper
• Percale Sheet Set
• Latex Pillow
• Graphite Memory Foam Pillow

Materials: Cotton, linen, silk, down alternative, latex, memory foam | Product Variety: Sheets, pillowcases, duvet covers, quilts, blankets, weighted blankets, shams, pillows, duvet inserts, mattress protectors, mattress toppers, bedding bundles | Certifications: Standard 100 by Oeko-Tex, GOTS | Return Policy: 45 days (180 days for mattress toppers)

West Elm

West Elm isn’tjust packed with on-trend furniture and decor—it’s also filled with eye-catching linens that would look great on any bed. We’ve tested four sheet sets from the brand—including Tencel, cotton percale, linen, and organic percale options—all of which proved to be durable and well-made.

West Elm ticks all the bedding boxes, offering quilts, comforters, blankets, and sheets in a range of colors, prints, and textures. And if you use West Elm’s Build Your Own Bedding Set feature, you can piece together a custom bedding set—mixing and matching items within the same collection until you have exactly what you need. The site also sells bedding necessities, like pillows, duvet inserts, and mattress pads. And many of its bedding items come with GOTS, RDS, and/or Oeko-Tex certifications.

Though West Elm’s shipping policies suggest otherwise, we’ve found the store offers free standard shipping on most bedding orders. Items typically ship within four to five days. Unfortunately, West Elm’s 30-day return window is one of the tightest on our list.

Real Simple Selects-Approved Products:

• 400-Thread-Count Organic Percale Pleated Edge Sheet Set
• Organic Washed Cotton Percale Sheet Set

Materials: Cotton, polyester, linen, eucalyptus lyocell, down, down alternative | Product Variety: Sheets, pillowcases, duvet covers, comforters, quilts, throw blankets, shams, pillows, duvet inserts, mattress toppers, bed skirts, bedding bundles | Certifications: Standard 100 by Oeko-Tex, GOTS, RDS | Return Policy: 30 days

Quince

If you want luxurious bedding that won’t break the bank, Quince is the perfect place to turn. The brand sells splurge-worthy essentials at mid-range price points, so its site is packed with bedding that looks and feels more expensive than it is. We’ve tested five sets of sheets from Quince, and they were soft, lightweight, and made of high-quality materials.

Quince also sells duvet covers, pillowcases, and blankets, and all of them are made of top-notch materials. You can score organic cotton bedding in four cozy weaves: silky sateen, crisp percale, soft flannel, and plush velvet. You can also find options made from flax linen, bamboo, Tencel jersey, and mulberry silk. And you can pick from a range of cozy cashmere throws.

Except for the Mulberry silk sheets, all of these essentials are refreshingly affordable. And though Quince gives you lots of options, it makes shopping a breeze. Color options are clearly listed under every product, and the brand offers free shipping as well as 365-day returns.

Our only qualm with shopping at Quince is that you can’t expedite shipping. Most items arrive within six to nine days, and we found there’s nothing you can do to speed things up.

Real Simple Selects-Approved Products:

• Luxury Organic Sateen Sheet Set
• European Linen Sheet Set

Materials: Organic cotton, linen, Tencel jersey, bamboo, mulberry silk, cashmere, down, down alternative | Product Variety: Sheets, pillowcases, duvet covers, quilts, throw blankets, pillows, duvet inserts | Certifications: Standard 100 by Oeko-Tex | Return Policy: 365 days

Walmart

Walmart is loaded with budget-friendly home essentials, so it’s a great place to stock up on bedding. Because Walmart is so big—and its website is so wide-ranging—its bedding section is tough to find. But once you’re there, you’ll have over 40,000 options to sift through.

Walmart sells every kind of bedding you can think of. We’re talking sheets, pillowcases, comforters, and quilts—you can even find pillows, duvet inserts, and mattress pads. There’s bedding fit for every mattress size, including harder-to-find sizes like twin XL and split king. Just remember that Walmart is both a seller and an aggregator, so to avoid third-party sellers, you have to filter by “Walmart” under “Retailer.”

Walmart offers 90-day returns on most items, which you can mail in or bring to the store. And its customer service representatives proved attentive and helpful every time we chatted with them. The store also provides free on orders of $35 or more, and many items ship in just two days. Unfortunately, its third-party sellers are a little less predictable.

Real Simple Selects-Approved Products:

• Coop Home Goods The Eden Pillow
• Better Homes & Gardens 400 Thread Count Hygro Cotton Bed Sheet Set (Better Homes & Gardens is owned by Real Simple’s parent company, Dotdash Meredith.)

Materials: Cotton, polyester, linen, silk, wool, velvet, down, down alternative, foam, buckwheat | Product Variety: Sheets, pillowcases, duvet covers, quilts, comforters, throw blankets, shams, pillows, duvet inserts, mattress toppers | Certifications: Varies by product | Return Policy: 90-day returns for items shipped and sold by Walmart

Wayfair

Wayfair is a destination for all kinds of home goods, and its bedding selection doesn’t disappoint. Visit the online store, and you’ll find over 50,000 kinds of bedding—and many of those options are both stylish and affordable.

Though Wayfair’s bedding selection is expansive, we found it easy to navigate, particularly if you go in with an idea of what you’re looking for. You can filter by type of bedding, bed size, material, and more. The site sells everything from sheets and pillowcases to down comforters and duvet inserts. You can even find bed skirts, weighted blankets, and heated throws. Most of these products cost less than $175, and they’re made from a range of materials, like cotton, linen, and chenille. The only downside? Wayfair lists products from dozens of brands, and it’s not easy to filter out third-party sellers.

Wayfair offers free shipping on orders over $35—an easy threshold to meet—and gives you just 30 days to return most items. Customer service is also accessible: You can reach them via phone, text, or email if you ever have questions or concerns.

Real Simple Selects-Approved Products:

• Sijo French Linen Sheet Set

Materials: Cotton, polyester, linen, silk, velvet, chenille | Product Variety: Sheets, pillowcases, duvet covers, quilts, comforters, throw blankets, shams, bed skirts, pillows, duvet inserts, bed skirts, electric blankets | Certifications: Varies by product | Return Policy: 30-day returns

Target

When it comes to bedding, Target strikes the perfect middle ground. The big-box store wins on variety, offering everything from pretty comforters to hypoallergenic mattress pads. But since the retailer has a curated feel, you can reliably find stylish stuff there.

Target sells over 4,000 bedding sets, over 2,000 comforters, and over 1,500 sheets and pillowcases. But since you can filter by bed size, color, materials, and more, all those options are easy to sift through. The store’s curated in-house brands (like Opalhouse, Threshold, and Hearth & Hand With Magnolia) make shopping even easier. Once you’ve found an in-house brand you love, you can head straight there and filter out the other options. Some of Target’s bedding is also backed by certifications. It sells a few organic bedding items, which are GOTS-certified, and many others are Oeko-Tex certified.

One of the best things about Target is that it offers 90-day returns. And while the retailer charges a $6 standard shipping fee, we’ve found it waives that charge on orders over $35—which is a pretty low threshold to meet. There are other ways to order, too: Many items are also available for in-store pickup or same-day delivery through Shipt.

Real Simple Selects-Approved Products:

• Sealy Molded Memory Foam Bed Pillow
• Beckham Hotel Collection Pillow
• Threshold 400 Thread Count Printed Performance Sheet Set

Materials: Cotton, polyester, linen, eucalyptus lyocell, bamboo rayon, silk, wool, down, down alternative, latex | Product Variety: Sheets, pillowcases, duvet covers, comforters, quilts, throw blankets, shams, pillows, duvet inserts, pillow protectors, mattress toppers, bed skirts, bedding bundles | Certifications: Varies by product | Return Policy: 90 days

Lands’ End

You might know Lands’ End as a clothing company, but the retailer sells a lot more than classic jackets and flannel shirts. The store’s bedding section is buried on its website, but once you get there, you’ll find items that are cute, cozy, and competitively priced.

There are great bedding basics, like cozy patterned cotton sheets and colorful down comforters. But you can also find very specific products, like pleated cotton bed skirts and monogrammed baby blankets. This variety makes Lands’ End a great one-stop shop for bedding. And the range of colors, prints, and price points makes it easy to find what you’re looking for.

Although Lands’ End's bedding doesn't boast as many certifications as you’ll find elsewhere, all of its down is RDS-certified, meaning it's sourced responsibly, and much of its bedding is machine-washable.

As you shop, keep in mind that Lands’ End only offers free shipping on orders over $99, but it does offer a generous 90-day return policy on most items. And you can reach customer service via chat, phone, or email.

Real Simple Selects-Approved Products:

• Premium Supima Cotton Percale Bed Sheet Set
• Premium Supima Cotton No Iron Sateen Bed Sheet Set

Materials: Cotton, polyester, linen, wool, down, down alternative | Product Variety: Sheets, pillowcases, duvet covers, comforters, quilts, blankets, shams, pillows, duvet inserts, pillow protectors, bed skirts | Certifications: RDS | Return Policy: 90 days

Nest Bedding

Nest Bedding specializes in top-notch mattresses, but it also sells cozy bedding. The brand offers a small range of sheets, blankets, and comforters, making it easy to outfit your bed from top to bottom.

Its site doesn't overwhelm you with options, which could be good or bad depending on your shopping preferences. For those who prefer quality over quantity, we think this site has the perfect selection. It sells sheets made of Tencel, bamboo, cotton percale, and cotton sateen—and we’ve tested all of these options. We noticed that Nest Bedding’s sheets are typically very breathable, durable, and cool to the touch. But the brand also sells silk pillowcases, throw blankets, and wool comforters. Many of its products are Fair Trade and Standard 100 by Oeko-Tex certified, meaning they’re made sustainably and free of harmful chemicals.

The brand offers free shipping on orders over $75, but there’s no way to speed up delivery. (When we ordered sheets through the website, we were limited to standard shipping.) It's also worth noting that its 30-day return policy is a little short compared to some other bedding brands. Overall, we love how user-friendly Nest Bedding’s website is. And though we didn’t need it, we appreciate that customer service is easy to reach. There’s a chat box on every page, so if you need anything, help is just a message away.

Real Simple Selects-Approved Products:

• Sateen Organic Cotton Sheet Set + Pillowcases

Materials: Cotton, organic cotton, Tencel lyocell, bamboo, silk, wool, jersey | Product Variety: Sheets, pillowcases, duvet covers, comforters, throw blankets, pillows, mattress protectors | Certifications: Fair Trade, Standard 100 by Oeko-Tex | Return Policy: 30 days

Casper

Casper stands out as a bedding powerhouse, offering high-quality goods that are surprisingly affordable, too. The brand’s “bedding shop” provides all the essentials, including duvets, sheets, blankets and throws, quilts and shams, mattress protectors, mattress toppers, and pillows. If you prefer saving money on a set, Casper’s bedding bundles combine these products for a better price.

The website is easy to sort through—you can browse a specific section if you know what you’re looking for, or you can peruse the “bedding shop,” where all products are organized on one scrollable page. Each product description includes clearly labeled sections detailing measurements and dimensions, materials and certifications, and warranting and shipping information. We tested a variety of pillows, sheets, and mattress toppers from the brand and found them to be cooling and comfortable. The Casper Foam Pillow with Snow Technology was a fan favorite due to its cozy heaviness and cooling properties.

The brand offers a 30-day return policy and free shipping, with orders typically arriving within two to four weeks from the placement date. Certifications vary between products: The down pillows are Responsible Down Standard (RDS), the foam pillows use CertiPUR-US foam and an OEKO-TEX Standard 100 cover, and the sheets cover a range of Global Organic Textile (GOTS), Oeko-Tex Certified, and GHCL Limited (Textile Division). If you have questions, you can use the chat function to talk with customer service or call a sleep specialist over the phone, though the expansive FAQ section will likely have the answers you’re looking for.

Real Simple Selects-Approved Products:

• Casper Foam Pillow with Snow Technology
• Casper Comfy Mattress Topper

Materials: Cotton, organic cotton, recycled cotton, recycled polyester, polyester, rayon, spandex, percale, Tencel lyocell, down, down alternative, sateen, foam, | Product Variety: Sheets, mattress protectors, mattress toppers, duvets, quilts, blankets and throws, pillows, bedding bundles | Certifications: Varies by product | Return Policy: 30 days

Pottery Barn

With its expansive selection of pretty much every home essential, it’s no surprise that Pottery Barn also offers high-quality bedding. From sheets and pillowcases to mattress toppers and duvet inserts, the brand has you covered. While the website’s general bedding tab might seem overwhelming, you can easily filter based on type of bedding, fabric, and color. You can also shop individual items from the brand’s predesigned “bedding looks,” making it easy for anyone to find inspiration.

We tested six of the brand’s sheet sets and found them to be breathable and soft. The Cozy Brushed Cotton Flannel Sheet Set stood out as the most breathable flannel sheet set in our testing, combining the cozy feel of traditional flannel with a refreshing airiness. Pottery Barn’s bedding is both Standard 100 by Oeko-Tex and Fair Trade certified, so you don’t have to worry about harmful chemicals. Pottery Barn also offers free shipping, though it’s worth noting that its 30-day return policy is one of the shorter ones we’ve seen. You can track your order as soon as it’s been shipped, and you can call, text, or chat with customer service on the site with any inquiries.

Real Simple Selects-Approved Products:

• Pottery Barn Cozy Brushed Cotton Flannel Sheet Set

Materials: Organic cotton, linen, Tencel, sateen, percale, velvet | Product Variety: Sheets, comforters, duvet covers, blankets, quilts, pillowcases, and shams, | Certifications: Standard 100 by Oeko-Tex, Fair Trade | Return Policy: 30 days

Riley Home

Offering exclusively bed and bath goods, Riley’s website is easier to navigate than more general retailers. It offers a very limited selection of comforters—it only offers one down option and one down alternative—though it makes up for it in its variety of sheets. Crafted in a fourth-generation textile mill in Portugal, the brand’s sheets felt extremely well-made in our testing. Those who prefer no top sheet may particularly like the Riley Sateen Sheet Set, which we found crisp and airy. And if you’re feeling sure of your purchase, the brand’s final sale section offers extra steep discounts.

Riley’s bedding products are all Oeko-Tex certified, and down products Responsible Down Standard (RDS) certified, ensuring humane animal treatment. The brand offers free shipping on orders over $100, which won’t be hard to hit. It also has a generous 60-day return policy, though returns will cost an additional $10. Standard shipping typically takes up to five business days, though you can select two-day shipping to rush your delivery. Riley’s customer service is available via live chat on the site.

Real Simple Selects-Approved Products:

• Riley Sateen Sheet Set

Materials: Organic cotton, four-layer cotton, brushed cotton, percale, linen, cotton cashmere, sateen, down, down alternative, Tencel | Product Variety: Comforters, sheets, pillowcases, duvet covers, shams, bedding bundles| Certifications: Standard 100 by Oeko-Tex | Return Policy: 60 days

L.L.Bean

Known for its wide variety of outdoor goods and apparel, L.L.Bean boasts a surprisingly expansive bedding selection. The bedding is hidden within the “home goods” tab, so you may have to dig a bit to find what you’re looking for. Luckily, the brand offers an abundance of filter options, including the options to filter by bed size, fabric, insulation, pattern, price, and more. Though these filters are helpful for those who know exactly what they’re looking for, the list of options may overwhelm some.

L.L.Bean’s sheets particularly excelled in our testing—we loved the brand’s flannel sheets so much that they earned two spots on our list of Best Flannel Sheets. Many of the sheet sets come in a variety of colors, and some even feature fun prints, making them an extra-versatile choice for any personal preference. Product certifications vary by product, so we recommend checking the item description before you make a purchase. You can get free shipping on orders over $75, and there’s a generous 365-day return policy (with a $6.50 return fee). If you have additional questions, the brand allows you to chat with an expert for instant answers.

Real Simple Selects-Approved Products:

• L.L.Bean 700-Fill-Power Sateen White Goose Down Pillow
• L.L.Bean Organic Flannel Sheet Set
• L.L.Bean Chamois Flannel Sheet Set

Materials: Cotton, cotton blend, cotton percale, flannel, fleece, pima cotton, wool | Product Variety: Sheets, comforters, blankets and throws, quilts and bedspreads, mattress pads, bed skirts, pillows | Certifications: Varies by product | Return Policy: One year

The 16 Best Sheet Sets of 2024, Tested and Reviewed