Which is Better for Concrete: Stain or Paint? (2024)

Which is Better for Concrete: Stain or Paint? (1)

Concrete Staining / acid, latex, mineral, paint, stain, vertical / August 31, 2021 / 4 minutes of reading

Second only to water, concrete is the most consumed material on earth thanks to its use in construction. Its prevalence in just about any structure and often-gray appearance has led to the usage of concrete stain or paint to bring color and beauty to this building material.

And that begs the question; what’s the difference between stain and paint, and which is better for concrete?

This issue plagues homeowners, property managers, and designers alike. In the professional world, concrete provides stability but lacks character and architectural vision uncolored. In the home, concrete flooring and walls need individuality to increase property values or bring joy to the occupants.

Whether or not you should use concrete stain or paint depends on an understanding of how concrete works and how concrete will function in your project.

Porosity and Permeability

Concrete construction can withstand some of the toughest weather conditions on the planet. But counterintuitively, that has a lot to do with both porosity and permeability.

Thanks to the curing process, concrete is made up of many holes, tunnels, and channels. These holes are difficult to see but account for the ‘natural’ texture of concrete.

During inclement weather, these holes allow moisture to pass through concrete–but never become trapped. Since moisture can freely exit concrete, the concrete won’t be damaged by the expanding and contracting moisture due to temperature changes.

Concrete stain and paint interact with concrete’s porosity and permeability in different ways. Concrete paint coats the surface with a thin film that forms on the surface. This traps moisture which damages concrete over time. Stain, however, colors the porous concrete surface without sealing it. This enables the free flow of moisture into and out of the surface.

Which is Better for Concrete: Stain or Paint? (2)

Concrete Stain or Paint: Use Cases

Whether or not you choose concrete stain or paint may also depend on its location.

Concrete paint may be utilized in smaller indoor projects often found in residential homes. Since the weather isn’t coming inside, it’s safe to use concrete paint for certain smaller projects. However, bear in mind that concrete paint will obscure concrete’s natural texture and isn’t suitable for concrete that takes a beating, such as a concrete floor.

For almost all exterior applications, concrete stain is the superior solution. However, what type of stain is going to depend on your project’s direction!

Acid & Mineral Stain Solutions

Horizontal concrete such as floors and walkways need a color solution that’s durable and practical rather than beautiful. In these cases, acid staining is best. Acid stains tend to give a marbled or polished look and can handle the wear and tear of everyday life, such as foot or vehicle traffic.

However, acid staining is only good for horizontal surfaces as they most often impart just one color or look. For vertical concrete, and particularly concrete that’s in the public view, architects, business designers, and others want to turn gray concrete into something beautiful.

Mineral stains are the superior vertical stain solution due to their versatility and durability. Certified Stain Technicians can use mineral stains to texture concrete to create any color, texture, and level of transparency required.

Furthermore, mineral stains are often paired with precast and/or textured concrete to create a transformative structure that imitates other building materials.

For example, a precast concrete slab textured and transformed by mineral stain with a masonry look can appear exactly like brick and mortar! Likewise, wood-textured concrete that’s been professionally stained can look just like the real thing from any distance.

Which is Better for Concrete: Stain or Paint? (3)

Final Thoughts

To sum it up, most interior projects and all exterior projects choosing between concrete stain or paint are likely better served by a stain solution. Furthermore, horizontal surfaces are best benefited from an acid stain, while vertical surfaces require a professional mineral stain solution.

Mineral stain particularly can transform concrete in ways that acid stain and latex paints simply cannot. Only mineral stains can provide decades of durability with the ability to create artistic and architectural visions through textured concrete and innovative application techniques.

We hope that we were able to help you better understand the differences between concrete stain and paint. If you’re looking to transform a home or other project, don’t hesitate to reach out and see why Nawkaw is the premier source of vertical concrete and masonry finishes!

Let’s Work Together!
Which is Better for Concrete: Stain or Paint? (2024)

FAQs

Which is Better for Concrete: Stain or Paint? ›

For almost all exterior applications, concrete stain is the superior solution.

Is staining concrete better than painting? ›

Concrete stain is the way to go when looking for the longest-lasting option for an exterior project in a high-traffic area. Stains penetrate the concrete, so it won't suffer from peeling and chipping the way concrete paint that sits on the surface can.

What are the disadvantages of stained concrete? ›

Cons of Stained Concrete Flooring
  • Concrete can crack over time.
  • It may require additional insulation for warmth.
  • It can be uncomfortable to stand on for long periods.
  • Limited options for repairs or changes in the future.
  • Staining may not produce uniform results.
Jul 28, 2022

What are the cons of painting concrete? ›

CONS
  • Paint doesn't penetrate into the surface like concrete stains do, so weathering and normal wear and tear could cause peeling over time, especially if you don't prepare the surface properly.
  • May require reapplication or occasional touch-ups, especially in high-traffic areas.

Is stained concrete worth it? ›

By staining your concrete flooring, you can transform even the most industrial-looking concrete floors into a versatile look that's fit for all kinds of home styles. From outdoor patio spaces to living rooms, staining your concrete may be that secret ingredient that makes your flooring perfect for your home.

What lasts longer paint or stain? ›

A stain will need to be reapplied after 2-3 years while the paint will last between 5-10 years before it needs to be recoated.

What are the advantages of stain vs paint? ›

One particularly notable benefit of using wood stain is its cost-effectiveness when compared to painting. Staining requires fewer materials and less prep work, making it a budget-friendly choice if you're trying to keep costs low. In addition, stains dry quicker than paint, allowing time for multiple applications.

How long does concrete stain last? ›

If properly taken care of, Concrete dye will last as long as the concrete itself. However, projects using Concrete Dye MUST be sealed every 1-2 years depending on exposure to retain the original color. If not properly cared for, the color could significantly fade requiring an additional application of dye.

What color stained concrete is best? ›

The most popular colors for concrete stains are earth tones including browns, tans, and terra cottas. Gray, green and blue hues are also possible. Color choice ultimately depends on the desired appearance for the project.

What happens if you don't seal stained concrete? ›

Left unsealed, the colors will fade, water marks may be an issue, and stains can penetrate leaving ugly oil spots where the service guy left his old jalopy parked on the driveway. It's pure and simple, the job just won't last without a good sealer.

How long will painted concrete last? ›

While painting concrete can last several years, you must use a high-quality product engineered for concrete surfaces. A cementitious coating will yield the best results. It's important to remember to seal your concrete to ensure long-lasting color and durability to the elements.

What paint is best for concrete? ›

There are two types of concrete paint: acrylic latex and epoxy paint. If you're looking to redo your basem*nt or garage walls, acrylic latex paint is easy to apply and affordable. Epoxy paint is best for outdoors and surfaces that you walk on such as your garage floor, driveway, walkway, or patio.

What is the best color to paint a concrete patio? ›

There is no best color to paint a concrete patio. Most people stick to neutrals like gray, brown, black, and white. But you can feel free to paint your concrete patio in any color of the rainbow that inspires you, or a combination of colors for a stenciled design.

Should I paint or stain my concrete? ›

To sum it up, most interior projects and all exterior projects choosing between concrete stain or paint are likely better served by a stain solution. Furthermore, horizontal surfaces are best benefited from an acid stain, while vertical surfaces require a professional mineral stain solution.

What are the disadvantages of staining concrete? ›

Lack of innate durability is a big drawback for water-based stains. Because the color is created by pigment settled in the pores of concrete, it is subject to fading. While the pigments are UV-stable, they can wash out over time with exposure to water.

Will concrete stains peel off? ›

When concrete is stained properly, the color won't fade, chip, or peel away. Although it looks beautiful, you can treat stained concrete the same way you treat any other flooring.

How long does concrete staining last? ›

Depending on the concrete sealer used, it's usually recommended to seal the concrete every couple of years to keep the color from fading. If you choose a high-quality concrete stain and sealer, you may be able to shorten the period between resealing to every 3-5 years.

Does stained concrete scratch easily? ›

Concrete floors that are stained and sealed don't just look beautiful but are also very durable. But this does not mean they are invincible. If you don't take good care of them, they can develop scratch marks, become dull, and wear out over time. This happens much faster if the seal isn't applied properly.

Does stained concrete fade in the sun? ›

However, in addition to the earth tones you find in other stains, dyes also provide more vibrant colors than the other products. Another difference is their UV stability. Concrete dyes use pigments that are not UV safe and will fade when exposed to sunlight.

Does stained concrete require maintenance? ›

Implementing a daily cleaning routine is vital to maintain the beauty and cleanliness of your stained and sealed concrete floor. Regular sweeping or dust mopping removes dirt, dust, and debris that can scratch the surface or dull its shine.

References

Top Articles
Latest Posts
Article information

Author: Edmund Hettinger DC

Last Updated:

Views: 6036

Rating: 4.8 / 5 (58 voted)

Reviews: 89% of readers found this page helpful

Author information

Name: Edmund Hettinger DC

Birthday: 1994-08-17

Address: 2033 Gerhold Pine, Port Jocelyn, VA 12101-5654

Phone: +8524399971620

Job: Central Manufacturing Supervisor

Hobby: Jogging, Metalworking, Tai chi, Shopping, Puzzles, Rock climbing, Crocheting

Introduction: My name is Edmund Hettinger DC, I am a adventurous, colorful, gifted, determined, precious, open, colorful person who loves writing and wants to share my knowledge and understanding with you.